9/10/2013 1 Comment Just Being Mean...![]() So I just read an piece on TheRoot.com. Basically, the author explained that the Washington Post put together a list "The 10 D.C. Guys We've All Dated." So I guess since the Washington Post put out a mean spirited list about White men, a Black magazine would just have to follow suit. "10 Types of Guys that Black Women have Dated" is a list of cleverly described, but basically undesirable guys. It talks about "The God," who is apparently ideal, on paper, but horrible to be around in person. Or the "Mr. Disappearing Act," who like his name disappears after being told "I really like him." Anyway, I guess my question is, "was this really needed." I mean, aren't there enough negative portrayals of Black men in media.? Why does a media site that is supposed to speak to and for Black communities putting out a list like this? To answer my own question, I really do not know. I doubt that the author was thinking that she was supporting negative stereo types, or that she adding fuel to the purportedly troubled relationship between Black folks and their relationship partners. In fact, I think she thought her list was funny, and that it was harmless. But as a Black man, I do feel harmed. The essentializing of Black men is not better or worse that the essentializing of Black women, or Black people in general. So though I can not assume that the author thought that she was doing something that is actually harmful, I also can not assume that she would be so dense as to not understand that her list was just mean... What do you think? Am I trippin?
1 Comment
vanessa davis
9/10/2013 10:42:27 pm
You are right. It wasn't needed, nor was it particularly comical, but as an opinion piece, it is what it is. Maybe she has had issues with these types of men, and as misery loves company, she chose to air here dirty laundry in a way that wouldn't point the finger directly to her. Maybe peer pressure from her editor-in-chief or her fan base led her to write the article. Who knows? You can never know what is going on behind the scenes or in the mind of an author unless you ask him/her. As an author yourself, I think you should ask that question directly to her. There has to be a way to get in touch with her in order to find out. Then maybe she will give the real reason rather than the cop-out reason she gave in the article. Challenge her, because as we authors all know the pen is mightier than the sword.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
About the Author...I'm an African American man with a Ph.D. in Counseling Psychology. I'm married. I am a professor, a clinician, a social justice advocate, a multicultural competence trainer, a dog owner, an ex-professional photographer (i.e., people paid me, lol), and a self proclaimed nerd, who loves Sci-Fi, Anime, Zombie fiction, cooking shows, character studies, anti-heroes, and telling people about things that I like... Archives
June 2015
CategoriesAll Advice Cbt Cultural Competence Culture Dating Emic Ferguson Internalized Oppression Internalized Racism Love Masculinity Men Mindfulness Multicultural Police Power Privilege Psychology Race Racism Relationships Romance Safety Women |